Could patenting fundamentals be right?
-Raghavendra S.
-Raghavendra S.
Ruling upholding Apple’s design patents may be a setback, impacting consumer choice and welfare
The turf battle between two mobile phone companies, who
between them sell more than half the smartphones sold worldwide, are
locked in more than 50 courtroom battles in 10 countries, captures the
degree to which the control over patents have become synonymous with
technological innovation. The latest verdict from a U.S. court in favour
of Apple, upholding its claim that Samsung has violated six of its
seven patents, has made even non-geeks take notice of the all-out war
between the two companies.
Apple is suing Samsung
with infringement of four of its design patents and three utility
patents, whereas Samsung is counter suing Apple with five of its patents
pertaining to wireless communication (3G and 4G LTE patents).
Certain
technologies start off as innovation of one company, and evolve into
the de-facto industry standard for others to follow — this has been
historically true. For instance, in the automation industry companies
did not sue each other for ‘replicating’ cars having a chassis and four
circular wheels.
Apple’s claim that the design of
Samsung’s smartphone and tablets with thin rectangular cuboid bodies,
and the rounded square icons as a violation of its design of the iPhone
and iPad would seem unreasonable when seen on a similar scale.
Nonetheless, with the current verdict and the patent system, these
design patents are being upheld and might be a setback, impacting the
range of choice for consumers.
Design patents are
applicable to the ornamental design of functional equipment. Apple holds
the physical design patent for its iPhone and iPad. Four design
patents, the current verdict and the patent system, these design
patents are being upheld and might be a setback, impacting the range of
choice for consumers.
Design patents are applicable
to the ornamental design of functional equipment. Apple holds the
physical design patent for its iPhone and iPad. Four design patents, the
ornamental designs of iPad, iPhone in white and iPhone in black, and
the round square icons on the screen of these gadgets, are the
infringements Apple is accusing Samsung of, and as a proxy other
Android-based smartphone makers. In the latest ruling from the court in
San Jose, California, the jury has agreed on the violation of all but
the patent for iPad design, yielding a sweeping victory for Apple with
$1.05 billion in damages and a prospective ban on a range of Samsung
products. The striking similarity in the design of Samsung gadgets, both
physical design and interface at many places, with that of Apple
products is now the biggest problem for Samsung. The injunction of
banning certain Samsung smartphones and tablets in other countries might
get stronger with the U.S. court verdict, affirming the stance taken by
the German court in August 2011, banning Samsung Galaxy Tab 10.1 in
German markets.
The interface for touch-based
devices available today invariably has some basic functionalities such
as multi-touch recognition and tapping screen for zooming and scrolling.
Apple is again staking claim and has successfully got a ruling against
Samsung in the U.S. court for patent infringement as it had the utility
patent for these algorithms.
Apple has three utility,
or application, patent violations in the lawsuits against Samsung.
Patents on interaction features with touch-based devices such as
enlarging documents by tapping the screen, ‘bounce-back’ feature when
scrolling beyond the edge of a page and the technique of distinguishing
between single and multi-touch were used to show that Samsung had copied
from Apple.
These features Apple is suing Samsung
for have become an industry standard so to speak. With the trend of
rulings in favour of Apple, it will render a double impact: One is, of
course, it will mandate research and innovation leading to better
technologies. Secondly, it will also make it a fierce battle of
Intellectual Property and patents between companies as a means of
getting an edge over competitors.
Innovation, at times, needs to be measured in more ways
than design patents. Making products affordable by building upon an
existing trend is also one of the means of sustained innovation. Apple
could be using the arsenal of its patents to tie down the galloping
Samsung smartphone business.
Claims of design and
utility patent infringement of fundamental ideas, although legally
validated hasn’t easily sunk in among the consumers. In India, Samsung
smartphones outnumber any other vendor including Apple, and it has
naturally left a distaste for this entire saga among consumers.
In
one of the utility patent infringement, Apple is suing Samsung for the
‘Slide to unlock’ feature. Graphics are being circulated on social
networking sites, that Apple has then violated Maruti Suzuki’s Omni,
which also has a ‘slide to unlock’ feature to open the side door. Not to
equalise domains, but some ideas are very fundamental and to patent
these basic ideas is a regression in innovation.
With
the current legal framework and the Intellectual Property Rights
regime, one can only hope to see more innovation and better competition
and not innovation to kill competition.